Waiting for Superman

I can’t decide if it’s good or bad that education is under the microscope these days. Having a child who is in his last year of preschool, I welcome any and all discussion that leads to positive changes in our schools. However, it does remind me of my days working in conservation. I can’t help but feel a little depressed after hearing story after story about how “bad” things are.

Recently, I started reading articles about a new documentary about the downfalls of the public school system, Waiting for Superman. Being a product of public schools myself, I couldn’t help but have the same knee jerk reaction as many of my friends — “I went to public schools, and I turned out just fine!” I decided I needed to see the film, particularly since this would be one of the few documentaries (and I’ve seen a lot of them, trust me) that did not support my preconceived views.

After seeing the movie, I must say am surprised at how much attention it has gotten. I cannot disagree that public school has failed the students depicted in the film, and that we owe these children a better education. I was heartbroken watching families packed into auditoriums raucously cheer and quietly weep after seeing whether they would win a slot into a better school via a lottery system. At the same time, Waiting for Superman addresses such a narrow piece of education reform, a huge and complex issue. Nothing I have read since becoming a parent leads me to believe that charter schools are the answer. Yet the Gates Foundation and the Obama administration would disagree with me.
AdvertisementOf all that I read about the movie, the article I think resonated the most with me was “The Myth of Charter Schools”. In it, Diane Ravitch points out that “The annual Gallup poll about education shows that Americans are overwhelmingly dissatisfied with the quality of the nation’s schools, but 77 percent of public school parents award their own child’s public school a grade of A or B, the highest level of approval since the question was first asked in 1985.” She also expands on the point briefly mentioned in Waiting for Superman, that not all charter schools are created equal. In a national study of charter schools conducted by Stanford economist Margaret Raymond, 17 percent of students scored higher in math when compared to public school students, while 37 percent performed worse than students in a public school and 46 percent scored no better or worse than their peers in public school. Ravitch joins the chorus of those who watched the film who were disappointed that teachers are depicted as a large part of the “problem” in schools.

I certainly don’t have the answers, but I hope Waiting for Superman helps propel education reform to the top of the political agenda. Because our kids shouldn’t have to wait.

So, why are charter schools suddenly seen as the solution to the myriad of problems facing our schools? Have you seen Waiting for Superman? If you are an educator, what is your take on the movie?

Written by: Nicole Basham

About Nicole Basham 793 Articles
A native Austinite and soccer-playing mom, Nicole uses her 10-year-old son as an excuse to rediscover her hometown through his eyes. In Thoreau's words, her mission is to "suck out all the marrow of life", or in her son's words, to cultivate in him a love of "advenchers".

1 Comment on Waiting for Superman

  1. Hi,

    i home schooled my daughter from the middle of first grade through the end of fourth. she begged to go to public shcool for fifth so we enrolled her. she is in Brookhollow Elementry in Pflugerville. she loves it and is soooo happy. i have visited and with my “i hatted public school” filter turned off (on purpose) i was able to see so much love and caring, support and nurturing, education and fun, even though i didn’t necessary like the whole experience. i agree that there could be lots of impovements in the public school system and i support the system in doing the job it is doing. we, as parents, can not depend on the public school system to be everything for our children. We can treat it like a buffet; take what we like and leave the rest. I also have a 28 year old whom i raised in and out of the system and he is doing great. Lisa

1 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Tweets that mention LiveMom.com – Dedicated to building a better village » Blog Archive » Waiting for Superman -- Topsy.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.